Probably for the first time since February we finally had the whole gang together once again. We had agreed to do a new Shuls N Shpayz visit the first Friday of June, however we had not many any headway by Thursday as for where to pray nor where to eat. All I knew was that it would be terrible weather and raining so this would factor into my decision. On Thursday night, I did some research and aggregated some old ideas into an email and sent the choices to the group. Still we were undecided by the middle of the day Friday except that my suggestion of Cafe Katja in the Lower East Side was acceptable. I proposed the Carlebach Shul on the Upper West Side due to its reputation for spirituality and the singing of the entire liturgy, in the style of Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach. Since most of the synagogues I still want to go to (Park East, Fifth Avenue, Bialystoker) are Orthodox there is often the contentious topic of the mechitzah, which does not exist in egalitarian minyanim, and the latter situation of which our group is familiar with growing up in Conservative communities. So when one who shall remain nameless reminded us of his disdain for the mechitzah, I then scrambled to find an egalitarian minyan and because of the weather which I did not want to battle too much I decided to find a service within walking distance of my office. Enter the Actors Temple, appropriately situated in the Theater District, though long since populated by actors (at least those of much acclaim). Borrowing from its Wikipedia entry, it dates back to the roaring 20s when the entertainment business was largely based in New York City, and when a lot of vaudeville, theater, TV, and nightclub performers went there, among the likes of Sophie Tucker, Jack Benny, and The Three Stooges. With the entertainment industry moving to California in the 30s and 40s, the synagogue went downhill though somehow has managed to stay afloat all these years. How, I do not know. Currently, they lease space to dance groups and double as a theater when there are no services happening, but this has all occurred within the last 10 years. When I walked inside, unlike many other synagogues in the city, there was no doorman. As soon as you walk in, there are stairs going up. I looked around for a coat room but did not see one. I left my umbrella on the stairs and continued into the sanctuary. It was an odd scene, a very long and narrow room with walls covered in wood paneling that reminded me of the family room in my house growing up, probably circa 1970s and large circular industrial light fixtures emanating an eerie glow from above. The vast majority of the seats were empty although it was less than 10 minutes before the Friday night service was scheduled to begin. I found the 3 of them in a row off to the right towards the front and sat on the aisle, put my jacket on the back of the chair and took off my galoshes which are lifesavers in this monsoon NYC weather. I then headed to the back to grab a siddur and returned to the seat. I opened it up and it was Sim Shalom just the same as the one I had grown up with, English on the left Hebrew on the right. Before the service began, the rabbi (who would also turn out to double as the cantor) came up to us and asked where we grew up and from what background we came, we all answered Conservative, our answer to which she appeared satisfied. There was a feeling of loss at the Actors Temple (officially Congregation Ezrath Israel), and people were scattered all over the room with seats upon rows just empty. Apparently when they transformed to a part-time theater they ripped out the old pews and put in removable cloth chairs and there is a mirror along the side wall for rehearsals that is covered by a curtain during services. The bimah is essentially a stage as there are curtains and lights and everything (not active during Shabbos of course). When we began, I was disappointed when she skipped right over Yedid Nefesh normally my favorite prayer to start Erev Shabbat. In fact, several prayers were skipped and in L'kha Dodi we ended up doing only verses 1, 2, 5, and 9. After almost every prayer, the rabbi/cantor would stop and add some thoughts. This service was not going to be a quick one. On multiple instances she also mentioned the expectation of a speaker who was late. Who this person was and what she would be speaking about I had no idea. When this speaker finally arrived, she was announced and the rabbi/cantor asked her if they could get through most of the prayers before having her speak. At this point, Neal nudged me to inform me that we would be leaving prior to this speaker since I had made a reservation at 9pm downtown and Alisa was going to meet us there. While we will likely not return to the Actors Temple, it was very cool to see the stained glass memorials to stars of the past and think of the history that once occurred in the space. There are 2 redeeming factors about a prayer experience at the Actors Temple: the atmosphere is very peaceful and somewhat spiritual and it's a good bet that anyone leading a prayer has a good voice, since it is after all the Actors Temple. Right before the president was to deliver announcements we made our escape, grabbing our umbrellas back out into the downpours on West 47th Street. To get to Cafe Katja in the heart of the LES on Orchard Street, we walked to the Times Square 42nd St station and hopped on the A downtown to West 4th Street. Meryl was elated when she realized what station we were, as she thinks of it as the quintessential Greenwich Village station and because she used to go to NYU for grad classes. From there we went to the BDFM platform hoping to catch a D train to Grand Street. Instead a D never came and we counted 2 F trains and 1 M before we decided to opt for the F to Delancey and walk west to Orchard. At Delancey, Meryl and Neal took the escalator and ended up on the way other wrong side of the street so Julia and I had to wait for them. Finally we headed west on Delancey and got to Orchard where I thought we had to make a right so we went up the street which was mostly dark and desolate until I noticed the house numbers were going up so we had to reroute back the other direction and cross over Delancey to head towards Broome. Naturally as we crossed Delancey the trade winds picked up immensely and umbrellas rendered useless. Finally down Orchard and across Broome, Cafe Katja was in sight with its wrought iron sign blowing back and forth. Upon entering, I was surprised to find out how spacious it was. Having read online that it was only 25 seats and the hostess telling me it was small when I made the reservation, there are 2 distinct sections, one with a great island bar and some tables and chairs from there to the windows and then past a half-walled section in what must have once been a narrow store space through which they broke the wall. When we got in, it seemed as though the host was going to seat us at a wall table 5 across. Then we were given the choice of a table in the center or another one soon to be vacated in the back. For sake of less wait, we took the center table. It is a neat place with the appearance of sitting at a kitchen table, not pretentious, paper napkins rather than cloth. First we ordered drinks and then I briefed everyone about what I had read had been ordered here before that was good: the cheese stuffed sausage, the beef goulash and the mac-and-cheese-like spatzle, and sides of cucumber potato salad and roasted carrots. As an Austrian restaurant, Katja is also home to an impressive selection of Central European beers, they can be ordered in 3 sizes including 1/3 liter and half liter. I decided to do a bit of sampling so I got the smaller the 1/3 liter, the Austrian Stiegl lager to begin. They also carry a few Hofbrau Haus brews like the Dunkel which Neal had. When it came to the food, we ordered a few pretzels with spread to start off with which included a couple dips, one of which turned out to be pure creamy butter and the other, liptauer (a spicy cheese spread made with sheep milk cheese, goat's milk cheese, quark cheese, or cottage cheese) that was absolutely amazing. And of course Alisa had them bring the traditional spicy mustard. Pretzels made such an impression on me that night that the next day while we were exploring Roosevelt Island, I stopped at Starbucks and got one of their mustard-stuffed pretzels which was good but not as great as Katja pretzels. When we were ordering the main courses, I told everyone I planned get the roasted carrots and the cucumber potato salad as sides to share but my suggestions were rebuked in favor of the expected large portion size of the main dishes. Looking back, this was the right call and when I return to Cafe Katja I will make sure to order these side dishes (it turned out that didn't even have the roasted carrots available that night so no sleep was lost). Along with Neal and Meryl, I ordered the beef goulash. I was a bit skeptical at first considering I associate goulash with Hungarian cuisine but given the proximity of the countries and the history as the Austro-Hungarian empire, there was no skepticism to be had. Whereas Hungarian goulash is much more of stew/soup with chunks of meat, this Austrian goulash (which turned out to be the only thing on the menu not from pork) exactly succulent, emphasis on the tender. No knife was required to dice the meat on my dish, it broke down from standard contact of the fork. I was also excited to have the spatzle alongside it which is soft egg noodles and a type of creamy cheese over it. It occurred to me there were no spoons on the table and I was missing out on the awesome goulash broth so I voiced this concern out loud and thankfully Neal came to the rescue with a suggestion to mix the spatzle with the goulash in order to absorb the broth: pure genius. The portion was just perfect and the taste of the dish was like none I'd had in a while and hardly comparable to Hungarian goulash. Austrian goulash which I had no idea existed, is in a world of its own (though I was disappointed that the wienerschnitzel was pork-based even though I specifically remember only having beef schnitzel in Vienna). Julia had the "seared hickory smoked salmon/kale/mashed potato" while Alisa ordered the "Emmentaler sausage/savoy cabbage/quark dumplings". I tried a quark dumpling and fell in love with it. Having never heard of quark previously, we asked and were told it is sort of similar to cottage cheese or ricotta, but has no salt added. Wikipedia says "it is made by warming soured milk until the desired degree of denaturation of milk proteins is met, and then strained". It was delicious. Alisa said she was not impressed by the sausage which was stuffed with Emmentaler cheese. Before the end of the meal, I ordered a second 1/3-liter beer, this time a Radeberger pilsner, which I have seen before at some bars throughout the city. Overall, it was a forgettable Shabbat experience with an excellent meal, hugely distinct from the heaviness of German dishes at Heidelberg. We will return to Cafe Katja.
The Actors Temple on West 47th Street
Actors Temple inside view of bima
Actors Temple looking out from bima with women's gallery above
Cafe Katja, 79 Orchard Street
Pretzel yum, with butter and liptauer dips
the roasted carrots I wanted to get
Emmentaler sausage with quark dumplings
seared hickory smoked salmon with kale and mashed potatoes
Austrian beef goulash with spatzle